I see, thanks for explaining! Are you saying that there is no way to get thermostats working with Alexa in your local network by using pimatic?
Alexa / Amazon Echo: Easy way to control MAX! Thermostats
@guybrushmr80 As far as I know the smart home features that echo supports on the local network are very limited. It’s just switching and dimming lights. No temperature, no colors, no sensors etc.
I am also interested in this feature. Maybe there would be a possibility to use the dimming machinsm. Say…
Dimm to 20% is 20 °c
And in the plugin configurable:
On is always 18°C
And off is 14°C
Before I did it with ha Bridge this way.
If I have some time I will make a pullrequest.
If I’m not mistaken, OpenHab uses a Hue-Emulation. Does the Hue Bridge support thermostats? I thought it’s only about lights? If OpenHab indeed lets the Max! thermostats pretend to be lights, how is it possible the temperature can be set via voice commands for something that is considered a light? Is this because of the color-temperature some lights support? That would be great as it wouldn’t require a weird workaround.
@guybrushmr80 No, Hue emulation doesn’t expose thermostats. Openhab use their own Alexa skill: https://github.com/openhab/openhab-alexa
This might be a good template for pimatic, though. If one doesn’t mind to open pimatic to the internet.
@guybrushmr80 No, Hue emulation doesn’t expose thermostats. …
But as mentioned above, at least you could control the MAX Thermostats as if they were light bulbs. I‘m using ha-bridge and get basically 3 different functions:
- Schalte Heizung aus -> set temperature to 16 degrees
- Schalte Heizung ein -> set temperature to 21 degrees
- Schalte Heizung auf < number> -> set temperature to <number>
Shouldn’t it be possible to set up
a dummy switch that can be controlled with Alexa and have a rule that changes the temperature whenever that switch is triggered? I tried that yesterday but I’m struggling with setting the Max! Thermostat to “comfy” - “mode” seems only to support “manu” and “auto”.
Which plugin do you use … pimatic-max or pimatic-maxcul ?
I have implemented the max support for the pimatic-maxcul. For me it works well.
currently i make the changes for the “normal” heating devices. ( DummyHeating/ pimatic-max )
But maxcul is ready. Maybe someone can test the changes too?
The on/off temperature is comfort and eco temperature.
After this test i would create the pull request.
Just download the changed version of the echo plugin.
# **stop pimatic first** cd /**pimatic-folder**/node_modules/ rm -rf pimatic-echo git clone https://github.com/treban/pimatic-echo.git cd pimatic-echo npm install # **start pimatic again**
I’m using pimatic-max - pimatic-maxcul is requiring additional hardware, replacing the cube, right?
not necessarily. i have flashed my cube with the cul-firmware. but this is a other topic.
I think this evening i will have implemented the other thermostats also.
currently i dont now to which temperature i should translate the on/off commands.
I think the easiest way to turn the heater on/off would be to set them to comfy/eco. But I’m not sure how to set this in a rule… probably super simple but I just don’t get it.
The normal heating devices and also the max-devices (it extends the build-in heating device)
don’t have a comfy/eco temperature.
Only the max-cul plugin provides this settings.
I think the best way would be to implement this values in the pimatic core heating device template,
instead to make this in the echo-plugin.
but I can see and toggle the comfy/eco setting in the UI!?
awesome! I have it a try and I think we’re almost there. Unfortunately whenever I ask Alexa to turn the heater on/off, pimatic seems to freeze. At least I get an “Could not connect (xhr poll error), retrying…”-error in the GUI. I setup the devices with the following parameters:
- hueType: Switch
- active: Yes
- additional names: Wohnzimmerheizung, Heizung im Wohnzimmer
Alexa finds two devices, based on the names above.
might also be an issue with my Max! setup - when I toggle to eco/comfy it also doesn’t work. The error is “error [pimatic]: Command was rejected”. Not sure if it worked before your changes.
EDIT: Setting the temperature also doesn’t work, same error message. Reading the temperature from the wall thermostats seems to work fine.
EDIT2: OK, for some thermostats it seems to work - from time to time. So the error occurs for some all the time for others not. I was thinking an unstable connection could be the issue but the one that doesn’t work is next to the cube… regardless of the issue I have I think the echo plugin needs to handle the error to avoid crashing pimatic.